"At the end of the day, Israel will have to deal with the threat of Hamas
rockets. The big question is whether to do it now or wait, like Israel did
in Lebanon - and look at the results"
[Dr. Aaron Lerner - IMRA: It should be noted that "moderate" Mahmoud Abbas
is not proposing to disarm Hamas or to destroy the military capability
described below but instead to put all gunmen on the PA payroll and absorb
all the military equipment and structures into the PA security system.]
Jerusalem Issue Brief
Institute for Contemporary Affairs
founded jointly at the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs
with the Wechsler Family Foundation
Vol. 6, No. 23 11 March 2007
Iran Is Building "Hamastan" in Gaza
Brig.-Gen. (res.) Shalom Harari
· There is a growing strategic alliance between Iran and the radical
Palestinian forces in the territories. Hamas says it will build its society,
economy, and army with the help of the Islamic world, mainly Iran, instead
of the West.
· Iran is involved in supporting both the Islamic factions and Fatah,
as well. Today, at least 40 percent of Fatah's different fighting groups are
also paid by Hizbullah and Iran.
· Hamas Prime Minister Haniyeh does not speak from the parliament.
Rather, he makes his declarations from the mosque every Friday. The Arabs
are very aware of the images they project. The head of the government
preaching from the mosque creates the image of a new caliphate being built
inside Gaza.
· Hamas thinks it can build a new southern Lebanon in Gaza, and this is
what it is busy doing. Hamas is seeking to build anti-tank and anti-aircraft
systems that will neutralize Israel's current ability to easily penetrate
Gaza, by using new kinds of missiles that were used in Lebanon.
· Hamas is also trying to fortify the cities in Gaza in which it has
its main rocket and weapons factories. If Israel again attacks deep into
Gaza, Hamas hopes to confront it with something like what was seen in
southern Lebanon - reserves of Hizbullah dug in deep under the earth.
· The IDF will have to enter Gaza in a very wide-scale operation in the
next year, if not in the next six months. The IDF prefers not to enter Gaza
because of the high cost in Israeli casualties, but Israel has to defend its
citizens. The big question is whether to do it now or wait, like Israel did
in Lebanon - and look at the results.
The Growing Influence of Iran
There is a growing strategic alliance between Iran and the radical
Palestinian forces in the territories. Iran is seeking to surround Israel
from three sides - from the north, by rebuilding Hizbullah; from the West
Bank, which has not been successful so far; and from Gaza.
Hamas feels that it has succeeded in breaking the siege that the Western
world tried to put on it, and that it does not have to respond to the
demands of the West. Hamas says that instead of depending on the West, it
will build its society, economy, and army with the help of the Islamic
world, mainly Iran. Iran is sending weapons and experts to Hamas, and is
also training Hamas security forces. Hamas members are being trained in
Iran, where they are learning various aspects of guerilla and terrorist
warfare.
Iran is involved in supporting both the Islamic factions and Fatah, as well.
Today, at least 40 percent of Fatah's different fighting groups are also
paid by Hizbullah and Iran. Many Fatah members are sitting on the fence.
They don't know which side to take and, in the meantime, Hamas is growing
stronger with money sent from Damascus and Iran.
Egypt had sent 100 experts to Gaza half a year ago, but today only two
generals are left, and even they prefer to spend most of their time in Tel
Aviv, for their own safety.
Two Different Palestinian States
We are seeing the formation of two Palestinian "states" that behave
differently - one in Gaza and the other in the West Bank.
Look at how the new Hamas leadership rules in Gaza. Prime Minister Haniyeh
does not speak from the parliament, a five-minute drive from his home.
Rather, he makes his declarations from the mosque every Friday. Haniyeh and
Abbas also differ in how they dress. Haniyeh comes dressed like a sheikh.
The Arabs are masters of preaching and speaking, and are very aware of the
images they project. The head of the government preaching from the mosque
creates a new image - of a new caliphate being built inside Gaza.
For the last twenty years, the Islamic bloc has had 40 percent support among
the Palestinian people inside the territories. It does not have 62 percent
support, which was the result in the parliamentary elections. Yet Fatah
today is still disorganized and split, and it cannot translate its support
into votes.
Abbas' threat to hold elections is an empty one. He does not have the
ability to implement elections in the territories. If he cannot succeed in
holding internal elections for Fatah, his own organization, he will not
succeed in holding general elections in Gaza and the West Bank.
In the West Bank, Fatah still has much better control, but Hamas is trying
to gain strength there. Hamas tried to build up its forces in Bethlehem and
in the Hebron district but failed, both because Israel fought it and also
because of pressure from Fatah.
Seeking a New Hamas-Friendly PLO
Abbas and the Arab states around Israel were ready to negotiate and
compromise. Now there is no compromise. Hamas does not recognize Israel, nor
does it recognize the position of Abbas as head of the PLO since Hamas does
not recognize the PLO. Hamas says that in order for the Palestinians to
unite, the PLO must change. Damascus-based Hamas leader Khaled Mashaal is
trying to build a new PLO, either by taking over at least part of the
control of PLO institutions or by building a parallel structure.
Hamas Prepares for War
We are seeing the continued growth of the Islamic forces in Gaza, especially
after the war in Lebanon. Hamas thinks it can build a new southern Lebanon
in Gaza, and this is what it is busy doing. With the support of Hizbullah,
Syria, and Iran, arms and ammunition are flowing through Rafiah on the
Egyptian-Gaza border every day, both above ground and through the tunnels,
in order to build "Hamastan."
Hamas is increasing its Kassam rocket production and is also improving its
rocket capabilities in order to be able to hit major Israeli cities such as
Ashkelon, Ashdod, and others. If Hamas acquires 122 millimeter Katyusha
rockets, it can reach the center of Ashkelon.
Hamas is seeking to build anti-tank and anti-aircraft systems that will
neutralize Israel's current ability to easily penetrate Gaza, using new
kinds of missiles that were used in Lebanon. It is also trying to fortify
the cities in Gaza in which it has its main rocket and weapons factories,
such as Rafiah and Khan Yunis.
If Israel again attacks deep into Gaza, Hamas hopes to confront it with
something like what was seen in southern Lebanon - reserves of Hizbullah dug
in deep under the earth. They have air conditioning experts for the
underground tunnels they are constructing. They have concrete experts to
build bunkers. They have communications and intelligence experts. They have
experts for every field connected to the development of weapons and rockets.
In Gaza there are between 80,000 and 100,000 automatic rifles and machine
guns. This is the most armed people in the Middle East except for Somalia.
In 2006, thirty tons of TNT was brought into Gaza. If the Arabs succeed in
bringing in the latest anti-aircraft and anti-tank rockets, then they will
not only shoot at the Israeli army but at Israeli civilian targets as well,
such as buses, because these rockets have a longer range.
The IDF will have to enter Gaza in a very wide-scale operation in the next
year, if not in the next six months. The IDF prefers not to enter Gaza
because of the high cost in Israeli casualties, but Israel has to defend its
citizens. If there is a continuing military threat in the south that
involves continued rocket fire into Israel which could hit a strategic
target, then there could be an Israeli invasion of Gaza. At the end of the
day, Israel will have to deal with the threat of Hamas rockets. The big
question is whether to do it now or wait, like Israel did in Lebanon - and
look at the results.
* * *
Brig.-Gen. (res.) Shalom Harari is a Senior Research Scholar with the
Institute for Counter-Terrorism (ICT) at the Interdisciplinary Center in
Herzliya. He served in the territories for twenty years as a senior advisor
on Palestinian affairs for Israel's Defense Ministry. This Jerusalem Issue
Brief is based on his presentation to the Institute for Contemporary Affairs
in Jerusalem on January 9, 2007.
This Jerusalem Issue Brief is available online at:
http://www.jcpa.org
Dore Gold, Publisher; Yaacov Amidror, ICA Program Director; Mark Ami-El,
Managing Editor. Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs (Registered Amuta), 13
Tel-Hai St., Jerusalem, Israel; Tel. 972-2-561-9281, Fax. 972-2-561-9112,
Email: jcpa@netvision.net.il. In U.S.A.: Center for Jewish Community
Studies, 5800 Park Heights Avenue, Baltimore, MD 21215; Tel. 410-664-5222;
Fax 410-664-1228. Website: www.jcpa.org. © Copyright. The opinions expressed
herein do not necessarily reflect those of the Board of Fellows of the
Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs.
The Institute for Contemporary Affairs (ICA) is dedicated
to providing a forum for Israeli policy discussion and debate.
To subscribe to the Jerusalem Issue Brief list, please send a blank email
message to: brief4-subscribe@jcpa.org
|